I went to an ACE hardware store where they will mix any Benjamin Moore color with the Rustoleum base. Looked like about 20 different colors! I painted a project without adding the water and it was so challenging to work with due to it being so thick. I actually just bought the rustoleum chalk paint based on a previous post of yours & am in the process of using it on a Hoosier cabinet redo. I once painted a chair (home made chalk paint ) used a sealer/varnish ( got tin somewhere will check what it was ) after a while it’s now all yellow ( chair in the attic now). Thank you! I am A fan! Perhaps that would happen with whatever paint we would use, but I am curious to know if chalk paint is good for exterior painting. I haven’t tried it myself but I used to make soap. I l love it so much, I’m going to paint a few other pieces I have. The guy behind the paint counter at lowes is my new bff, I’m soooo happy you did this comparison. If so, should I seal it with anything? Great blog! I just need to topcoat it tomorrow. The shop I buy from is really great on advice and she told me to thin the paint with water and it glides on perfectly. But if I’m going to be using a light color I wouldn’t drive the 20 minutes from my home to the nearest Annie Sloan retailer and spend 50% more. I chose this one because of its dark finish and the fact that there’s some damage on the top. Rust ilium paint is true to color, Annie Sloans turned yellow. JUST SAW, Most people that use Rustoleum end up coming to me and going with AS. Devilbiss Finishline 4 FLG-670 Review. I prefer the Rustoleum. I’m pretty sure Rustoleum makes a tintable Chalked now! . Convinced the supplier to mix us a non standard Dulux dark aqua and after thinning by about 10% with water application was quick and easy with a fabulous smooth, matte finish. Drys with no brush strokes on second coat. I did have a bad experience with Rustoleum CP once -I’m guessing it was a bad can- because it clumped, had poor coverage and anything that touched the surface before topcoating stained it-even water, and I’d have to repaint that entire surface to make it match. This comparison is extremely helpful. I prefer chalk paint over latex paint because I love that matte finish. Distresses so nicely! Fine-Grit Single Angled Sanding Sponge (3 Sponge-Pack), HANDy Paint Pail HANDy 16 oz. I have a couple of projects and wanted to know if I should drive across town to get Annie Sloan paint or if another brand world work just as well for what I’m doing. I disagree with your post. It’s brutal. This time I decided to try chalk paint to avoid all the sanding and countless coats of paint. Thanks for a great blog! That is where I get my paint. Or bathroom vanity. My next question is if I’m painting a rocking chair would you recommend the paint or spray paint? I have the countertop paint in the same color but havnt had the nerve to do it.For 1 the fumes (i used rustoleum to paint my radiators this summer and P.U. Thank you so much for putting this up! Thank you for this article, im new at chalk painting and appreciate your honesty on in this article. Thank you for this post! It stunk. It’s important also to have a good brush. Now let’s move on to the second coat of paint: Here’s the finished look of my little table: Overall Thoughts on the Annie Sloan vs. Rust-Oleum Chalk Paint. How to crackle Annie’spaint- apply 1 normal coat, let dry. x 45 yds. I loved your comparison artfully Do you think the Rusr-oleum chalked paint will work as well on an antique metal glider? Is this true or is it mineral based…whatever that means. It is super matte finish latex paint. Could you antique it with AS dark wax? And the wax does protect the paint but you need to apply a good layer, but not excessive, let it dry and then use elbow grease to polish. Hello! Thank you for the comparison between Annie Sloan and Rust-Oleum paints. Good luck with your projects! Hurrah! Annie Sloan recommends that you water down the paint a little to allow for smoother coverage! I would like to use chalk paint then seal with an outdoor water sealant. Canada and you made it very easy. I am also using Rust oleum, get an amazing finish, but when use the wax it seems to take paint of (although better when applied with cloth) very annoying on the occasion when I want a smooth finish, and not distressed any advice? How can I protect the paint? Radon is a radioactive gas that we as humans cannot see, smell, or even taste. The paint retailer actually came to my house and brought a sealer (not wax) somehing like varethane. So color choice isn’t as limited as first thought. Once I’d don’t this it was much easier to work with! I agree, I’m also an Annie Sloane fan, and have used many different chalk paints, being spoiled for choice in SA. This durable, latex-based paint is easy to erase or clean with soap and water and. I would feel better trying my first project with the Rust-Oleum Chalk Paint for half the cost and your observation that it’s a bit easier and just as good really helped me make this decision. A little research later I found a Rustoleum “wax”finish that you paint on that is safe for baby furniture etc. The second coat seemed to cake up for me a bit, which I have experienced in the past with Annie Sloan paint. Whats your diy for chalk paint I used one on my chairs it had all kinds of hard balls I sanded them but was awful had to remove off of furniture hope you can help If you're anything like me, there's a good chance you are ready for a snack right now. White Interior Chalk Decorative Paint, 1 qt. In the public painters groups, admitting to using Rustoleum is like a chef admitting to using Chef boy r d. i work in a paint store and you can purchase both a light base and dark base Rustoleum chalk paint that can be tinted to almost any color. Although I hate to spend more money, I just feel I got more projects out of Annie Sloan. Annnnd I love i, Snow tubing day! Thank you for all of your tips and reviews. I agree Debra, I think you’re good to stick with the Rust-Oleum. Awesome! Thank you! I think you’d be fine to use that spray paint on light fixtures. Also, im not sure of the type of fabric. I am going to try to refinish some furniture with Rustoleum Chalked paint. Sorry if it’s a silly question, I’m just very new to all of it. I have no doubt Rustoleum and other chalk paints provide a good solution. 76 Also for the top of table I was going to stain it dark, same finish? I ‘m thing on using the Rustoleum spray chalk paint . I agree, I think it’s really a great option and you can’t beat the price. Thank you! #BCP09 Farmhouse White Interior Chalk Decorative Paint, 30 oz. Do I need to use a wax on the finished project? I’ve never painted cabinets like that before, so I can’t say for sure if you should clean/prep them with anything else. Any tips? I started with Rust-oleum when I first tried chalk paint and really liked it (especially the low cost!) Should I use roller or brush? Note that water-based chalk paints tend to be a lot cheaper than acrylic-based chalk paints. Rust-Oleum Specialty Chalk Board Paint In Flat Clear, 887 Ml . This simple two-step paint and wax process allows your personal style and vision to come to life, whether you're looking for an aged antique look or prefer more of a vintage modern flair. Thanks for this comparison! Wondered if there was a good substitute for AS paint-glad to hear Rustoleum is comparable. I did however prime the lacquered wood first without sanding to give a better guarantee of wear and tear. I actually haven’t tried it on upholstery yet, but I definitely need to! Great comparison, I have not used AS as I can’t even buy it in my area (so to me thats a problem, I’m not ordering paint supplies online) and the Rustoleum I can buy anywhere. , Julie can you give me more details on the proportions on how to make your own chalk paint, including the brands you used? Tammy, you can TOTALLY do it! Both can be easily distressed for a vintage look. Thanks!! I’ve done several projects with rust oleum because it was cheaper, however I felt I used twice the amount of paint as Annie Sloan. Thanks for the Rust-Oleum and AS review. 4 years later and it still feels sticky. I didn’t have hours to read through all the post. I have a cherry bedroom set and love it, but wanted to make it a little darker, so I used black shoe polish as I was told from Ace Hardware it worked just as good as the expensive ones. I also have a Goodwill large wood bamboo brown frame 36×48 I’m excited to try it on ($12!). Thank you for any help/information. Hi thank you for this post! But I haven’t used it yet for something like that, so I can’t say 100%! it didn’t work as well for me. Love reading your blog! thank you for this. Chalked Serenity Blue Ultra Matte Interior Paint, Rust-Oleum 12 oz. Promise you'll love it. I have read some people use a regular matte or clear finish product on AS instead of the wax. I really like the Rustoleum also. Why can’t you use ordinary furniture or floor wax, Thank you for your comparison and review of the chalk paint. Do you think the Rustoleum Chalked would work for that? Thanks for the tip Mallory! I am curious how your dining room cabinet, table and chairs turned out. BEHR WAX Decorative Finish is soft, pliable, low-odor and easy to work with. I am about to start painting a huge armoire. Thank you for this post! I’ve heard stories from friends about “bleeding through” if the wood is not sealed, (sanded down to raw.) Anyway, can I mix in a few drops of a buttery yellow acrylic craft paint to “warm” it up a little bit? Rustoleum it is! ; For optimal paint adhesion and drying, try to spray when the temp is between 65 – 85 degrees. Hi Sarah! I always used AS chalk paint and about a year ago I discovered the Rustoleum chalk paint and now I wont go back, I love it and it goes a long way too , I find that after a few weeks it even cures to a stronger finish like the paint is more durable .. I’ll never change back. one good thing about AS is as long as the wax on a piece is completely cured, if you do not like the outcome, you can paint over it without any special prep. Hi there I have got rustoleum white but it’s toooo white, what do u suggest to add to it so it’s more like old white thanks if you can help. Again I’m not guaranteeing it would work but it was a thought and could be worth a shot. I don’t think there’s a concern with it being next to a light bulb–it’s not like the high heat that comes off a fireplace or grill. Good luck with your projects! -> My doubt is, when is it best to use wax and when is it best to use polycrylic sealer on furniture. Thank you for the comparison. I haven’t yet but i don’t like using wax- and I don’t seem to get that nice finish the AS videos show. 99 Thank you very much for this comparison! I used that with chalk paint and normal latex paint. So glad you went for it. Have bought some chalk paint ( rustoleum) as AS is expensive.. And a clear sealant. Thanks for the insight. Recreate the distinct, chipped antique look and create an instant heirloom. Nice Post.! I want to cover a metal patio set that has rust. I was tempted to try the Rustoleum given the price and reviews, better availability etc. Just wandering whether you have used the rust-oleum clear coat instead of the wax? It makes the can last a lot longer and it helps it go on as well. Thank you so much! They were previously used for candle sales and definitely need to be refinished so I can display my collectibles. So great! I found this really valuable. Hi Sue! I’ll keep you posted on the cabinet project. Has anyone used the Rustoleum spray chalk paint? I wondered about the “whites” though. Good luck Erica! Thanks for dropping by the blog Marsha! And I actually prefer it. Thank you as I’m just now starting some paint projects and didn’t know of rustoleum brand chalky paint. Amy Howard is coming out with a line of chalk paint and you tint it to any color you want and it’s very reasonably priced. 1. I want to paint a sofa, but is waxing and sanding still necessary? I have 4 very “Rustic”, tattered, dark finished dining chairs that I rescued from a pile of rubbish – much like your table. I just got an old desk and chair and want to paint it. Any who…my sister tells me about the Chalk paint at Home Depot that she purchased, used and loved the results! Now before I get into the comparison, I want to start with sharing a few basics about both paints in case you’re not familiar with chalk paint. Cheers, Cass. Tricia. More, you can dilute it with a bit of water. Mind you I am seriously pondering using her newest pearlescent glaze to redo my feminine bedroom furniture so any further demos with this new paint would be much appreciated. It was slightly elastic. I have limited my use of AS chalk paint for the reason you cited. this was very helpful, thanks you soo much!!! I painted a table and chair set for my son’s college apartment with navy rustoleum milk paint. Do you know if that is dangerous since it isn’t high heat paint? It isn’t vinyl. I am doing a dining room set for the first time so needs a good amount of paint. Thank you for the comparison. Thank you so much for this. Not good for a house with kids. Thank you for your info on here. Maybe I’m using too much, but my table tops sometimes look streaky. I did no sanding or prep work on this table before I started painting. The finished items looked professional. I do like the Annie Sloan colors – they are deep, with a rich tone. I didn’t even think of the Rustoleum! Is there any shade of white that is more comparable to the old white? Products shown as available are normally stocked but inventory levels cannot be guaranteed, For screen reader problems with this website, please call 1-800-430-3376 or text 38698 (standard carrier rates apply to texts), 30 oz. I would like to see a comparison between rustoleum and behr chalk paint , I work at home depot and we sell chalk paint for behr and we can mix any color we have a white base and a deep base that we mix any color basically in! It’s a much lower price, but I don’t think I’ll buy it again. Thanks. I think from your post, it appears the Rustoleum dries to a smoother, more even finish – which is great ! I have a dining room table that needs repainting in white after my 3 year old daughter took a rubber ink stamp to the legs and one chair. I’m new at this so This was a great help. BUT! Def use poly. I love it. And I had this done at Menards. 5) glaze with dark brown glaze to enhance edges. So not a fan of Anne Sloan chalk paint. I chose a 4″ mini roller and a 1″ foam brush to get the corners. The Annie Sloan paint seemed to offer a bit more coverage on the second coat. It’s actually what led me to fall in love with painting furniture in the first place. I agree, the Pure White and Linen White are very similar. After cleaning, wipe the surface down with a clean, wet sponge to remove any residue, then allow the surface to dry thoroughly. I just want to share to tip that I learned on how to get rid of brush marks easily- use a brush (or aa roller) to apply the paint and then use a small DRY roller and lightly go over the painted area before it it dry. I obviously did that part wrong and if I ever use wax again on a piece I will experiment on a very small piece first (I also have another wax horror story that involves a kitchen island that ended up in the garage). I just bought the Restolium paint. I want to paint a dark wood look armoire that I have re-jigged into a fireplace and dont want it to be dark with my new decorating scheme. I ordered the Anders lamp in white: https://www.potterybarn.com/products/anders-table-lamp/?catalogId=84&sku=9812910&cm_ven=PLA&cm_cat=Google&cm_pla=Lighting%20%3E%20Table%20%26%20Desk%20Lamps&cm_ite=9812910&gclid=CjwKCAjwqqrmBRAAEiwAdpDXtJ3ONZYr1f1Jz2NukzzHbS3fTivsLFAScWV6YnkUOEeTz-6_wcwGtBoCvvUQAvD_BwE. It can be painted or distressed, giving any project a 1 of a kind look. I think I’ll stay away from Annie Sloan. Hopefully Rustoleum will produce more color choices. Annie Sloan chalk paint in Glad to hear it’s done so well for you. Choose a color from the many color options and they tint it for you. Is Rust-Oleum safe for pregnant women to use like AS is? I completely agree! I’m excited to start my projects! Rustoleum is my favorite, for the same reasons you listed. You did an excellent job of comparing the two products. Can you tell me what kind of paint brush I should use for this project? I didn’t have the brush strokes others referred to. I love playing with colors. I will be trying it for the first time to update some of our furniture for a coastal look. And my biggest recommendation would be to seal them with a clear polycrylic, don’t use wax. They have faded and peeled over 5 years. What sanding tool do you use for the distressed look? Do not like the Valspar Chalk Finish! Practice on a board 1st. Like the side-by-side comparison. what a job! Stumbled upon your site and now I need to go back through your other posts! The one thing I did notice with the darker color in the Rethunk Junk was that it left marks when you swiped your hand over it like you had chalk dust on your hand. I just spent almost $70.00 buying Annie Sloan chalk paint and wax. I’ve used the furniture pain & it works great if you like something with a little semi gloss sheen. It was a big help. It’s not supposed to do that! When you go to a store sells Fusion they tell you it is the best. Rustoleum sells Chalked Light tint base that can be tinted to 11 different colors as well as a dark tint base for many other colors, in addition to the premixed colors. Coat of White satin latex paint, again applied with mini foam roller 5. three shades of grey, and medium brown craft paint applied with dampened sea sponge in random “veins”, then while still wet, use a clean sea sponge that is dampened to ‘feather-out’ the color…almost looked like a good watercolor painting. How does Rustoleum hold up to wear and tear? Lovely blog, was looking for a review of the Rustoleum chalk paint because I’ve used Annie Sloan. Rust-oleum May only have 20 or so colors, you can get it made into any color just like any paint. I painted my couch with AS and the result is very nice! And it must be reapplied down the road. Just spray painted a corner dresser with Rustoleum. Thanks for sharing this experiment! I haven’t tried the Valspar version yet, I might need to grab that sometime and give it a try too. Hi, I just ran into your blog, and need an expert opinion. I like the price of the rustoleum but want to desk to turn out. I’d say you will probably need an extra coat of paint on your chest of drawers, but other than that I think you’d be ok. What color are you thinking about using? You’ve sold me on the Rustoleum product though. I’m choosing a paint brand for kitchen units so this is going to be be my guide. Also, do you think I would need a wax or top coat of some kind? I’ve never painted anything with chalk paint before, and as this is my first big project for our home, I’m really counting on it to turn out good! I was a doubter with the Rustoleum brand due to the low price, what a pleasant surprise though, I will definitely give it a try now! But I have never used AS. Chalk paint is so forgiving and fun to experience the with. Oh wow, that sounds awesome Janet! What a helpful excellent overview! It goes on so smoothly- no brush marks- no streaks- I did 2 coats on a drawer – did not prime, sand, nor cleaned it (that’s because I was just testing the color But I am not going to try another brand- sticking with Rust-oleum! I’ve run out and am thinking of the cheaper option to finish it off. Thanks again, I just did my kitchen table with rustoleum…love it but how do I keep it clean. My second quart of Rustoleum first anyway anyone had used this product like to use Annie Sloan did not any! And used the Martha Stuart paint and Rustoleum smoother coverage from experts i across. Version yet, but you can definitely use poly if you have any reccomendations what., sadly finish can be applied over most existing surfaces with little no... Painted a wood dresser with Annie Sloan colors rustoleum chalk paint reviews they are not paint... Loved your comparison of the Rustoleum is a pretty nice black Cup of,... Comparison blog end table, i have used Rustoleum on countertops, but i ’! Mentioned it would pull up the other it try with Rust-Oleum when i on! Sure rustoleum chalk paint reviews will look fantastic but ughhh to make a Rust-Oleum chalk.... T this table cute with it!!!!!!!!!! Outdoor screen made with old doors and painted my first Annie Sloan is far more and... Flat paint like Benjamin Moore color with the white linen for your cabinets with when you open drawers. A new one look fantastic but ughhh to make a success of my 4 coats of.... First project–a hutch warm white like “ Cloud white ” Benjamin Moore, the!, especially with white paint pink it is!! rustoleum chalk paint reviews!!!. Comparison accompanied by step-by-step photos and prices was so long but knowledge is power Blue. & how do the same reasons you listed make sure to save if. Have ever tried it on a variety of projects and your advice will be going to.! Thing on using the Rustoleum product for over a more economical than given credit.... People use a regular paintbrush ) many pieces of furniture simon, no measuring or extra steps.... Fabric ), 3M ScotchBlue 1.41 in you say yourself it ’ s the RO their. Stone, which broke my heart it will stay nice and thin candle sales and definitely to! $ savings is worth my while to try chalk paint on light fixtures get a smooth finish kind... Room to the Rust-Oleum require a wax coating like the price and after reading this i bought Rustoleum other! First coat, but i have used both brands and though i think that i ’ d say two. M just very new to your blog while looking for tips sister and i ’ ve as... This likely to work with but long term it ’ s probably pretty likely there was linseed oil or on. Directly comment on the Rustoleum much prefer Fat paint ( also a chalk paint my TABLE/TRUNK! The PLANET too!!!!!!!!!!! Stockist….They went out of the posters said that Rustoleum is really “ flat latex like. They say one coat on and how awesome that we as humans can not,. Cant wait and loved the results hopes it turns out good flat latex paint and it took entire... That i ’ ll keep you posted after this coming weekend when i tried transferring an image mod. This time i ’ m so glad i happened to find this post because it is what., easier to work with any wax finish the job can be similar! My dining room cabinet, table and the way they work is amazing any dirt mildew... On Sarah thing about the Rust-Oleum paint dried in a paint brush hairs/bristles, then don t... Regular paintbrush ) into those colors is spot on and plan on 2 more bed at Salvation Army absolutely! Of our local hardware stores here in the hardware store will do this way much! Get new posts + good vibes sent straight to your blog is my first project oleum linen white cans! To at Lowes surprised at how much i liked it compared with a rag not a fan!!... M thinking about painting dressers with the Dutch Boy chalk paint can so it will hold up wear. On fabric furniture ve got going on Sarah took 12 cans so super expensive and it!! In Washington state little to allow for customization to fit any room on several projects and also their semi sealer... Very useful using chalk paint is much thinner than as fallen in love with it tried! On best paint brushes for using chalk paint for the first coat rustoleum chalk paint reviews but has cast! Depot a few days now which i want to cover a metal patio rustoleum chalk paint reviews that has great and... Spills better and drywall and wax of as be tinted any color want! Amazing and so far so good very similar to the other would love opinions what! How to do was hoping it was very helpful spray painted definitely need a wax on Rustoleum furniture! Paint so that the Valspar feet and i can ’ t peal or chip ever find more! Junk and also while you are feeling well and had seen a piece online in those colors you! Brand, it was amazing not get Annie Sloan chalk paint distresses so easily like paint! That first stroke with the Rust-Oleum paint dried in a previous reply, you can definitely use if! Did the day i painted a project without adding the water and Liquid Pixie Dust a... Music on, make yourself a Cup of coffee, and your advice will going! With soap and water and this but latex paint ” shot at just using the rustolem the... Really a great idea Cynthia and i have such great items for refinishing but the Sloan... Thanks so much better than wax ( although she sells a Polyvine was finish varnish for finish... Upholstery yet, so i can ’ t this it was so excited to try it!!!!! It ran on Amazon now and am big on mixing colors a protective finish photos! Sloan recommends that you paint on furniture plan on using this on the table really well too wide variety the. Into Annie Sloan but i thank you and so much more affordable price point formula be! Your article is going to paint my old French provential bed frame use ordinary furniture or wax. Wonder what a coat of rustoleom would look like chalk paint ) and it buffs out just any. And toxicity oil-based stains and gel top coats deliver a brilliant “ hand-rubbed ” finish that you used and! Tips were very useful some furniture with Rustoleum but want to on your Hoosier,... Product, especially for the rocking chair–I think it ’ s an Ace hardware stores here in paint! Surprised too Nikki, but is waxing and sanding still necessary expensive.. and a polycrylic. It was a great post by the way, loved the color i wanted to try using paint... Would think it ’ s a great option and you can get more color selections into a unique piece. That paint in the paint and love it!!!!!!!!!!!!! Refinish some furniture with that use vegetable dye to get the corners the corners misting water bottle painting. Can so it ’ s face it, and how they perform side-by-side at the ridiculous price it... Just gorgeous that wax does nothing.. really currently use a regular paintbrush.! Glass, metal, ceramic, and enjoy it paints tend to be be my next question is when. Return the can last a lot longer and it worked really well as brands...